ルーブリック - Percussion (Indian) Audition Rubric

A traditional 4-level, 100-point Indian percussion audition rubric scoring hand technique and bol production, composition recall, tala and laya, tone and dynamics, and improvisation within tradition.
4 - Exceeds Expectation 3 - Meets Expectation 2 - Approaching Expectation 1 - Below Expectation
Tabla or Mridangam Compositions & Improvisation
100%
__________________________________________________________
Hand Technique & Bol Production
20%
20 ポイント
Every bol is produced with textbook clarity and correct finger placement; na, tin, dha, ge and ta are unmistakably distinct....
15 ポイント
Bols are clear and correctly produced with minor inconsistencies in the more demanding strokes....
10 ポイント
Bols blur together and finger placement is imprecise; the syllables are hard to identify....
0 ポイント
Bol production is not established; strokes are indistinct and technically incorrect....
Composition Accuracy & Recall
20%
20 ポイント
Kaidas, relas, tukras and tihais are recited and played from memory with complete accuracy and correct development....
15 ポイント
Compositions are accurate and well developed with occasional small lapses....
10 ポイント
Compositions are partially recalled and development is incomplete or incorrect....
0 ポイント
Compositions cannot be recalled or played as taught....
Tala, Laya & Rhythmic Cycle
20%
20 ポイント
The cycle is held with absolute security; sam is always landed exactly and laya is controlled across all three speeds....
15 ポイント
The cycle and sam are secure; tempo changes are handled with brief adjustment....
10 ポイント
The cycle is lost in places and sam arrives late or early; laya is unstable....
0 ポイント
The tala cannot be maintained; the cycle and sam are not tracked....
Tone, Resonance & Dynamic Control
20%
20 ポイント
Excellent resonance and tuning with a wide dynamic range; open and closed strokes are precisely balanced....
15 ポイント
Good resonance and clear dynamic contrast; balance between the drums is mostly even....
10 ポイント
Resonance is muted or uneven and dynamics are compressed into a narrow band....
0 ポイント
Tone is poor, tuning is neglected, and dynamics show no control....
Improvisation, Tradition & Expression
20%
20 ポイント
Improvises inventively and idiomatically within the gharana or tradition, with authoritative phrasing and expressive nuance....
15 ポイント
Improvises competently within tradition with clear phrasing and appropriate vocabulary....
10 ポイント
Improvisation is repetitive or steps outside the tradition; phrasing is unclear....
0 ポイント
No usable improvisation and no evident grounding in the tradition....