ルーブリック - Piano (Classical) Audition Rubric

A traditional 4-level, 100-point classical piano audition rubric scoring touch and tone, note accuracy and technical facility, rhythm and tempo, pedaling and dynamics, and stylistic interpretation.
4 - Exceeds Expectation 3 - Meets Expectation 2 - Approaching Expectation 1 - Below Expectation
Prepared Repertoire, Scales & Sight-Reading
100%
__________________________________________________________
Hand Position, Touch & Tone
20%
20 ポイント
Efficient hand position and relaxed arm weight produce a singing, varied tone; touch is fully controlled in every texture....
15 ポイント
Good hand position and pleasing tone; touch is secure with minor unevenness in dense textures....
10 ポイント
Hand position collapses under demand and tone is harsh or shallow; touch varies unintentionally....
0 ポイント
Hand position and touch are not established; tone is uncontrolled and percussive....
Note Accuracy & Technical Facility
20%
20 ポイント
No wrong notes at tempo; scales, arpeggios, octaves and passagework are even, fluent and secure....
15 ポイント
Accurate playing with isolated slips; technical passages are secure with slight unevenness....
10 ポイント
Wrong notes recur and technical passages slow down or blur; fingering choices are inefficient....
0 ポイント
Note accuracy and technique are insufficient to perform the repertoire....
Rhythm, Tempo & Pulse
20%
20 ポイント
Rhythms are exact and the pulse is unwavering; rubato is stylistically informed and never destabilizes the tempo....
15 ポイント
Accurate rhythms and steady tempo with slight rushing in demanding passages....
10 ポイント
Rhythmic errors recur, subdivision is uneven, and tempo fluctuates unintentionally....
0 ポイント
Rhythm and tempo break down; the written figures cannot be identified....
Pedaling & Dynamic Range
20%
20 ポイント
Pedaling is clean, subtle and stylistically apt; the dynamic range spans a true pianissimo to a full, unforced fortissimo....
15 ポイント
Effective pedaling and clear dynamic contrast; the extremes are somewhat cautious....
10 ポイント
Pedaling blurs the texture or is barely used; dynamics stay within a narrow band....
0 ポイント
Pedaling is haphazard or absent and dynamics show no contrast or control....
Phrasing, Style & Interpretation
20%
20 ポイント
Deeply musical, stylistically informed interpretation with sophisticated voicing, direction and artistic nuance....
15 ポイント
Clear phrasing and appropriate stylistic choices; interpretation is convincing if conventional....
10 ポイント
Phrasing is literal, voicing is undifferentiated, and stylistic conventions are inconsistently applied....
0 ポイント
Playing is mechanical with no phrasing, voicing, or stylistic awareness....