Rubric - Timpani Audition Rubric

A traditional 4-level, 100-point timpani audition rubric scoring stroke technique and tone, tuning accuracy, rhythm and entrances, roll quality and dynamics, and orchestral style.
4 - Exceeds Expectation 3 - Meets Expectation 2 - Approaching Expectation 1 - Below Expectation
Orchestral Excerpts, Etude & Tuning Test
100%
__________________________________________________________
Stroke Technique & Tone Production
20%
20 Points
Relaxed, legato stroke that draws a full, resonant fundamental; mallet choice and beating spot are ideal at every dynamic....
15 Points
Good stroke and tone; beating spot and mallet selection are appropriate with occasional lapses....
10 Points
Stroke is stiff or struck, producing a thin or slappy tone; beating spot is inconsistent....
0 Points
Stroke technique prevents a usable tone; the drums are struck without control....
Tuning Accuracy & Pitch Changes
20%
20 Points
Tunes quickly and exactly by ear; mid-piece pitch changes are silent, accurate and confidently executed....
15 Points
Tunes accurately with minimal delay; pitch changes are correct with slight audible adjustment....
10 Points
Tuning is approximate and slow; pitch changes are late or noticeably out of tune....
0 Points
Cannot tune the drums accurately; pitches are wrong throughout....
Rhythm, Pulse & Entrance Precision
20%
20 Points
Rhythms and entrances are exact with an authoritative internal pulse; long rests are counted flawlessly....
15 Points
Secure rhythm and entrances with minor timing variation after long rests....
10 Points
Entrances are late or early and subdivision is uneven; pulse is unsteady....
0 Points
Rhythm, entrances and pulse are unreliable; the part cannot be followed....
Dynamic Control & Roll Quality
20%
20 Points
Rolls are perfectly smooth and evenly sustained at every dynamic; crescendi and diminuendi are seamless and fully graded....
15 Points
Rolls are smooth and dynamics are clearly contrasted; the softest rolls thin slightly....
10 Points
Rolls are uneven or gapped and dynamic changes are abrupt or narrow....
0 Points
Rolls cannot be sustained and dynamics show no control or contrast....
Musical Style & Orchestral Awareness
20%
20 Points
Stylistically authentic across periods, with expert muffling, note length choices and clear awareness of the orchestral texture....
15 Points
Appropriate style, muffling and note lengths; orchestral awareness is evident....
10 Points
Style and note lengths are inconsistent; muffling is applied haphazardly....
0 Points
No stylistic awareness, muffling, or sense of the surrounding orchestral texture....